Homepage > Joss Whedon’s Tv Series > Buffy The Vampire Slayer > Reviews > "Buffy" Jumped the Shark at the End of Season Five ?
« Previous : Robert Joseph Levy - "Buffy : Go Ask Malice" Book - Sci-fi-online.50megs.com Review
     Next : Joss Whedon Still F_ing Rules »

Mytelus.com

Buffy The Vampire Slayer

"Buffy" Jumped the Shark at the End of Season Five ?

Blaine Kyllo

Friday 7 July 2006, by Webmaster

Being among the first to watch good television programs has its drawbacks. Sometimes you see signs of these shows being past their prime just as the masses jump on the bandwagon.

I can’t imagine how frustrated early fans of Buffy the Vampire Slayer must have been when, at the last minute, the network told Joss Whedon, "Okay, why don’t you do a sixth season of this thing?"

Desktops: Free Upgrade this week

You see, Whedon and his writing team, knowing that the series was coming to an end at the close of season five, had decided to kill off their heroine with a dramatic flourish.

In bringing Buffy back from the dead, Whedon and his writers jumped the shark.

That’s not to say there wasn’t the occasional flash of brilliance from the team, but overall, Buffy should have ended at with season five, with the Slayer making the ultimate sacrifice. That was, after all, what the show was all about.

Unlock your equity at chip.ca

Beg your pardon? You haven’t heard the term "jump the shark"? Sorry.

Jumping the shark refers to the moment, the scene or episode, when an otherwise good television show has a creative lapse so significant, it can never recover; when the plot shifts from the peak, and starts sliding down the other side of the mountain.

The phrase was coined in honour of the Happy Days episode in which Fonzie, in a publicity stunt to help save Arnold’s Diner, dons a life jacket over his leather, straps on a pair of water skis, and jumps over a shark in a big tank erected in the parking lot of the hangout.

Jon Hein, who introduced the term but credits friend Sean Connolly with coming up with the phrase, notes in the companion website, JumpTheShark.com, that it was "the point at which the writers have clearly exhausted all possible creative ideas for the show."

The phrase has become so common that "jumping the shark" has come to refer to other cultural products - movies, music, celebrities, companies, organizations - that have started to decline. As in, "Paul Martin has so jumped the shark."

The Jump the Shark website is an encyclopedia of entries and discussions about your favourite (and not so favourite) shows and whether they jumped. Jump the shark moments can often be categorized, too. An example of "same character, different actor" is when Dick York was replaced by Dick Sargent on Bewitched. How about relying on a "special guest star" to maintain viewer interest, like when Nancy Reagan guest starred on Diff’rent Strokes? Or when David and Maddie "did it" and changed Moonlighting forever?

Among the television shows that the Jump the Shark community have decided never jumped are Barney Miller, The Odd Couple, Magnum, P.I., The Rockford Files, Fawlty Towers and The Simpsons.

I’ll bet you never look at Grey’s Anatomy or Lost the same way again.


5 Forum messages

  • "Buffy" Jumped the Shark at the End of Season Five ?

    8 July 2006 01:38, by angelusiredspike
    I disagree. Bringing Buffy back from the dead was not the jumping the shark moment. The jumping the shark moment in the entire series of Buffy The Vampire Slayer and in Angel was the change in Spike’s sire from Angelus to Drusilla. That was not only jumping the shark but the shark shreadding both series and their storylines to bits. Spike and Angel were throw away characters that are now two of the most popular and beloved major characters ever from these shows. To dismiss the sire storyline and change it to a very unbelievable and uncomfortable mess completely jumps the shark in my opinion. To my knowledge the reason for the change has not been addressed. It is my hope and the hope of Spike and Angel fans everywhere that this storyline will be rectified in the books and comics. The return of Angelus as William’s real sire is what the fans need.
  • Joss didn’t want to kill off Buffy, he wanted to show the end of an era and mark the beginning of the new more grown up Buffy in a new network. People complain about season 6 but they don’t understand how incredibly difficult it is to change the direction of a heroin, who has been invincible and perfect for 5 years and make her human. Everyone goes through what she went through, the wrong guy, the feeling that you don’t want to take responsibility for everything, when you wake and feel you don’t belong and need a change...Season 6 gave everyone in the show the chance to fuck up and stop being perfect American students. I think some of the best writing, character development and relationships happened in season 6 and nothing that happened in the first 5 seasons would have been as meaningful. Joss and his team always say they wanted to have characters everyone can identify with and in season 6 he got the chance to allow his characters to make mistakes and find their boundaries and learn from them. Looking at Angel, Firefly and Buffy, Joss Whedon doesn’t seem like the kind of writer who will be satisfied having his Heroin die for the “greater good”. As for "jumping the shark", you only have to watch Charmed to know what the true meaning of that expression is.
  • "Buffy" Jumped the Shark at the End of Season Five ?

    8 July 2006 14:20, by Anonymous
    This guy is obviously delusional. The show was all about female empowerment, and he seems to think that killing off the female heroine is the perfect ending for the show?! I don’t think so.
  • I’m surprised he didn’t credit the introduction of Dawn as the moment it jumped the shark. That seems to be the moment most people go for. It is the obvious choice, as not only does she just appear from nowhere, she is a REALLY irritating character. That said though, season 5 is my favourite season, despite Dawn. And I agree that they kind of jumped the shark with Buffy’s death, but not with killing, more the way they brought her back. They didn’t earn it. I know they said they did with all the Buffy being depressed crap, but that was just what made season 6 crap. The bottom line is, after a whole season leading up to her death, and a great finale moment, she was back after one episode. Also, when the hell did Fawlty Towers jump the shark? It ended purposely soon to avoid JUST THAT. And people to this day still say it should have gone on longer.
  • "Buffy" Jumped the Shark at the End of Season Five ?

    10 July 2006 16:26, by Anonymous
    This guy needs his brain-if he has one-examined! Buffy’s 6th and 7th seasons just got better and better. There was never any "shark jumping" with BTVS. And as for the person who’s all bent out of shape about Spike’s sire—Angel sired Dru, Dru sired Spike. It’s just like how Dru called Carla "Grandmum", Angel was Spike’s grandsire. Same dif-just a "generation" away.