Homepage > Joss Whedon Web Series > Dr. Horrible’s Sing-Along Blog > News > Dr. Steel vs. Dr. Horrible : Mad Scientist Showdown
« Previous : Neil Patrick Harris - "How I Met Your Mother" Sitcom - He’s nominated for Emmys
     Next : Joss Whedon - "Doctor Horrible’s Sing-A-Long" Musical - Thetvaddict.com Interview »

Coilhouse.net

Dr. Horrible’s Sing-Along Blog

Dr. Steel vs. Dr. Horrible : Mad Scientist Showdown

Thursday 17 July 2008, by Webmaster

Intellectual property is an ever-raging discussion here in The Age of The Internet. Often the lines between inspiration and imitation are blurred but today I give you an interesting case. You decide!

Long-time mad scientist Doctor Steel has, over the course of many years, made himself an infectious image. To do this he’s combined vintage war propaganda aesthetics, catchy tunes and an image of an asylum escapee who plots away in a secret lab and seeks to improve Earth with toys and total world domination. Through his website he’s pulled together an entire army of fans called Toy Soldiers, who organize events and distribute various Dr. Steel propaganda.

Left: Doctor Steel. Right: Doctor Horrible

Now there’s come along a Doctor Horrible. Produced by Joss Whedon and starring Neil Parick Harris, “Dr. Horrible’s Sing-Along Blog” is a website dedicated to video blogs starring a 30-something mad scientist who sings and wants to take over the world. In the site’s Master Plan, Whedon invites fans to spread the word, offers propaganda-style banners and promises a DVD release later.

Similarities beyond the singing mad doctor character include aforementioned propaganda-inspired banners, shiny gloves, goggles and an “Ask Dr. Horrible” segment - not unlike these “Ask Doctor Steel” videos. There is also the matter of the title itself : “Sing-Along Blog” is reminiscent of Doctor Steel’s Read-A-Long album.

Doctor Steel feels slighted by this endeavor and is rallying his troops in retaliation. Now that you’ve seen the evidence it’s time to cast your votes. Personally I’d like to see a bit of Doctor on Doctor boxing, shiny gloves and all.


2 Forum messages

  • Spoiler: Neither of those characters invented any of those motifs.
    • Dr. Steel vs. Dr. Horrible : Mad Scientist Showdown 23 July 2008 22:00, by Miss Zahrah
      Indeed, the mad scientist is hardly new, so lets just enjoy BOTH as there is certainly room for BOTH in this great big mad world of ours! There will be preferences to one or the other, but many fans will enjoy both, and no need to fight over it! Yes, it does strike many a toy soldier (Fans of Doctor Steel) as ’too close for comfort’ but it’s dangerous ground to tread to accuse others of plagerism. It could be that Dr. Horrible really brings a great influx of recognition to the genre and allows more recognition of Dr. Steel as well! Viva la World Domination! -Toy Soldiers Unite. Come the Utopian Playland!

      See online : Can’t we all just get along?