Felicia Day

When Felicia Day returns to The CW’s Supernatural for “LARP and the Real Girl” (airing Jan. 23), she won’t be the only one engaged in live-action role-playing aka LARPing. The Winchester brothers will also get in on the fun, and we’ve got your first look at Dean donning a medieval costume that you have to see to believe.

“We will discover that young Charlie Bradbury, in running from her past life, has found herself a new life in a new community,” executive producer Jeremy Carver previously told TVLine. “Basically, [she] has fallen into the welcoming arms of a community of LARPers.”

But not everything about this group is warm and friendly; Dean and Sam are there to investigate the death of two players.