Homepage > Joss Whedon Off Topic > Girls Who Bite Back : Witches, Mutants, Slayers and Freaks (buffy (...)
« Previous : Sarah Michelle Gellar - Elle Magazine Photoshoot Outtakes - Mid Quality Scans
     Next : Alyson Hannigan & Freddie Prinze Jr. - "Boys And Girls" Movie - Medium Quality Screencaps »

From Mountainpridemedia.org

Girls Who Bite Back : Witches, Mutants, Slayers and Freaks (buffy mentions)

By Elizabeth A. Allen

Monday 10 January 2005, by Webmaster

We need some superheroines now more than ever. We need witches, mutants, slayers and freaks to fight for us and along side us. Maybe Girls Who Bite Back, edited by Emily Pohl-Weary (Sumach Press, 2004), will help us find some.

Half the authors in GWBB think Buffy the Vampire Slayer epitomizes girl power. Let’s ask her. Hey, skinny blonde teenager, you star in your own TV show. You karate-chop through vamps and demons the way that a chef juliennes carrots! You’re strong, smart and always witty. You’re the coolest thing since Wonder Bread, right?

On second thought, maybe not. You see, Buffy, you ARE Wonder Bread. You’re perfectly white, just like all your friends. As Candra Gill points out in her essay "Cuz the Black Chick Always Gets It First: Dynamics of Race in Buffy the Vampire Slayer," any characters of color on the show are either subservient, dead, minor, or several of the above. Buffy, you’re supposed to be an Everygirl, but you aren’t. Your bourgeois, homogenous world isn’t as rich and as multi-colored as ours. You can’t be our superhero. You’re too boring.

We’ll get off the tube, then, and look into fiction. GWBB enthusiastically turns the pages of classics, looking for feminist inspiration. Catherine Stinson’s essay "Red-Headed Orphans Rule" directs us to a trio of feisty literary carrot-tops: Annie, Anne of Green Gables, and Pippi Longstocking. They might be what we’re looking for.

Hi there, Annie, cute comic-strip orphan. You overcome the squalor of an alcohol-soaked orphanage to win love and parental guidance in the form of Daddy Warbucks. That’s kick-ass. Could you be our hero?

Wait a minute. Stinson points out that you ARE just playing out the ol’ Cinderella myth, Annie. You get rescued by this prince/daddy figure, who, disturbingly enough, capitalizes on war bucks. We don’t want to say this, Annie, but you have this unnerving passivity. You’re, like, colluding with the patriarchy.

And Anne of Green Gables ... unfortunately, you’re pretty much the same. You’re smart and imaginative; you show independence in attending college and becoming a teacher. But then you settle with childhood crush Gilbert. Sorry, Anne, but you’re clinging to that man and breakin’ our heart.

Our superhero could be Pippi Longstocking, from Astrid Lindgren’s children’s books. How about it, Pippi? You lift circus strongmen over your head, laugh at policemen and merrily shock squares everywhere. To Stinson, you’re a perfect feminist icon. But not to us, not really. You’re amusing and entertaining, but you’re too far-out, with your pet monkey and your cannibal-king father, to be relevant. We like you, but, like Buffy, you’re not a superhero for us in this world.

If we can’t find a superhero among current examples, GWBB gives us another option. We can make our own! We’ll create a superhero of color: Gilla in Nalo Hopkinson’s "The Smile on the Face." She’s just an average teenaged girl who says no to the sexual harassment of one guy and yes to her gentle boyfriend wannabe. Gilla, we know how hard it is to speak one word, to spell out what you want. In this world, THAT’S a superpower.

We’ll make superheroes that we can identify with, like Sherwin Tija’s rounded, asymmetrical "Slumpyheroes." We’ll have agoraphobic, fragile abuse survivors, like in Rose Bianchini’s "Everyday Superhero." For her, each day’s living takes strength and exemplary courage. Once you think about it, the ordinary acts of surviving and thriving are true superpowers.

Our superheroes exist beyond the bounds of revisionist feminist fiction. They’re all around us. In fact, they wrote GWBB! Marc Ngui and Magda Wojtyra, you shall be our superheroes. In your clever comic "Crisis Girl in Spring Rolls!" you point out that making nifty hors d’oeuvres quickly should be considered a superpower. And Sophie Levy, you’re super too. With your trenchant essay, "Manifesto for the Bitten," you analyze our ambivalence toward the seductive and threatening figures of aliens, vampires and cyborgs. You GWBB contributors, you’re heroic, pushing forward your power, showing us how we can do it too.

So the superheroes aren’t out there. They’re in here - inside us, even. Carly Stasko’s essay, the best and truest of the lot, tells you "How to Be Your Own Superhero." In her words, superheroism sounds an awful lot like finding what you’re good at and what makes you happy, then striving, no matter what, to do good. We can do that! I mean, God knows it ain’t easy. You have to be super. You have to be heroic. But if you look everywhere and can’t find superheroes, then you must rise to the challenge yourself.

Super woman Elizabeth A. Allen finds herself surrounded by super women in Somerville, MA.


7 Forum messages

  • If everyone is supposed to be equal, what should it matter what race you are? If Buffy was black, she would be a hero? I can’t think Buffy is a hero because I’m black and shes not? Sunnydale was a town, as Mr. Trick says, full of "the caucasion persuasion". Hey, author. There are actually skinny blonde girls out there in the world. Black or white or yellow or red, what should it matter what color you are?
  • Wow, another meaningless rant. Maybe this author should buy season 7 cause it’s actually all the minorities that survive in that year. Also, one thing that should definatley adressed is that Buffy has always been a very open show when it came to sexuality and relgious beliefs.
  • Hello??? Kendra anyone? I mean, yes, she is dead, but she still got to be a slayer! And Rona? She’s still alive! I think this is a bit severe on the show because it DOES have a multi-racial cast and fanbase!
  • Screw that. I am mixed...part white, part black. Buffy is my superhero. I don’t care if she’s blonde, fat, white, black, asian, red hair, blue hair...whatever. She’s Buffy-slayer, scooby member, screw all I’m going to kick your ass-Summers. She and SMG are amazing. This article offends me on a few levels a) she refers to African American or Blacks as ’people of color’. Where does she live? The 1800’s? That’s really non pc. b) I think that she is making all people who are non-white look bad. She speaks with a ’we’ like we all share this stupid opinion. WELL WRONG. If this dilusional woman watched Buffy the Vamprie Slayer she would see that Buffy is anything but boring. I mean, for one SHES A FRICKIN SLAYER? How could that be boring all on its own? She sleeps with vampires, has pshyco witch friends, an imaginary sister, hell gods chasing after her and she’s died twice. Maybe even three times if you count flat lineing. And another thing...Kendra was a slayer and she was black. Robin Wood was on the show for an entire season. Son of a slayer, and had some power. And his mother was a slayer. She had a pretty influential role in the last season even if it was small. Also, Kennedy is latino, Rona is black, and you don’t see many red heads on TV. Buffy has had five or more. This article is so ignorant.
  • So it’s the fact that the major characters on Buffy are ’white’ that bothers this writer?? Well, if this writer had bothered to watch season 7, they would’ve realised that the character of Robin Wood, a major character, was NOT killed off! But I guess some people are just so quick to criticize!
  • "Also, Kennedy is latino"

    What? Did I miss that? It looks like I have to watch season 7 again :) Any hints as to which episode this was mentioned?

    Thanks.

  • If you actually read the article and not just this review, you’d know that the author *does* specifically address season 7 and all of the people of color who show up in it. Don’t criticize something you haven’t read.