Monday 26 June 2006, by doctor ferris. :

Well......the eyes are different shapes and color. The noses are different. The mouth and chin are a completely different shape and SMG is a brunette. I am so glad that I don’t buy People Magazine!

Tuesday 27 June 2006, by amanda :

Wow! That is scary!

Tuesday 27 June 2006, by Anonymous :

who is sarah michelle gellar? ... the talented one, that’s who! what an insult!

Tuesday 27 June 2006, by Anonymous :

OK...what the...?

Wednesday 28 June 2006, by Rodrigo :

what?!! sarah is far beautiful than ashley simpson!!! and sarah is natural ;) the nose are different (no one have you beautiful nose!) your mouth...your eyes... it’s absolutely different!!!

Thursday 29 June 2006, by Anonymous :

Who is SMG? The one that’s not the fake, and doesn’t look like a total idiot! A blind would be able to make the difference!! I agree with the one who said that she is the talented one!

Friday 30 June 2006, by Liz :

Compared? There is no comparing to be done! Sarah never had surgery. She’s talented as said and in the sense that unlike Ashlee, Sarah CAN sing. How dare People magazine remotely even suggest people compare the two. It’s an insult to Sarah.

Saturday 5 August 2006, by Anonymous :

Sarah is natural? HAHAHAHA. You must have missed the emmy pics wear you could see swolleness under her eyes and bandage marks. Also, she went from horrible buck teeth to perfect teeth. I told them apart easily, Sarah’s hooked beak is easy to spot a mile away.

Tuesday 5 September 2006, by Skyler :

Uhm, her teeth have always been the same as far is I can tell. Besides, whats wrong with a little teeth whitening? :D Sarah is way more prettier, and BETTER from my aspect.

Sunday 8 October 2006, by Anonymous :

They look so much alike, before i even saw this i was thinking wow ashlee looks like sarah!

Tuesday 24 October 2006, by Jana :

I happen to happen an unnatural obsession with Buffy The Vampire Slayer and Sarah Michelle Geller in general and its quite obvious that Sarah Michelle Geller is B. I cannot believe they would insult her like that.

Wednesday 1 November 2006, by Anonymous :

They look nothing alike, but I still can’t believe that is Ashlee, she doesn’t look at all like herself. Ashlee, you were cool when you were different!!

Friday 10 November 2006, by the RIGHT one :

well... to me they both look really very different. Both are beautiful =) and whoever said sarah has a hooked beak... i’ll bet yur an ugly fucker aren’t ya? ;) all the negatives are the comments from the jealous ones!!

Saturday 11 November 2006, by i am jaz pleased to meet you! sarah rocks!! :

how can they insult the most talented, beautiful acctress in all the world with "her"! i love sarah she rocks how can they be so mean to her! waa waa xx Jaz xx

Saturday 11 November 2006, by della erium :

If you read the subject line you’ll see the whole purpose of this was to compare them physically... not professionally. They are easily told apart by features mentioned in previous comments. But they both have very stunningly similiar smiles. Whether they reached the "look-a-like" status via plastic surgery or not they are both beautiful women. This photo comparison just proves it.

Thursday 16 November 2006, by Missytheslayer :

Sarah looks so different in this picture. So does Ashlee. I think the magazine more thank likely did some editing to the pics. As far as talent, Sarah and Ashlee both have talents, but Sarah kicks ass in the acting world. I think Ashlee has well... decent music, but now she’s a blonde and got all tan and looks like a barbie. like her slut sister. it’s disappointing. i used to like her. oh well. SARAH RULES!!!!!!!!!!! BUFFY LIVES!!!!!!!!

Wednesday 22 November 2006, by Anonymous :

ASHLEE ROCKS!!!!!!! iuh, sarah michelle gellar? that’s so... iuh! ashlee is so much more beautiful. maybe you people should wash your eyes or something?! and she’s so much more talented, i mean.... who’s more famous? who’s the star here? ASHLEE!!!! and don’t say she sucks... have you guys even seen her at chicago? so awesome!

Sunday 17 December 2006, by Anonymous :

’unlike Ashlee, Sarah CAN sing.’

Sarah is a terrible singer, which is why just about all of what she sang in OMWF was very heavily synthesized. She sounded like the eighties.



Monday 18 December 2006, by grecianstory :

i cant believe they’d compare her to sarah michelle galler. first off, sarah is beautiful, stylish, and a LOT more talented than sarah. i think they should compare ashlee to her sister jessica and leave sarah alone. xp

Monday 18 December 2006, by Anonymous :

Sono belle entrambe......I english people....I’m an italian boy....! I love both sarah and ashlee....bye! Italy 4ever!

Tuesday 26 December 2006, by Amoredeangelus :

Ashlee has had a lot of surgery done. Sarah hasn’t so i do not see how she can be compared to Ash. I love both but it really is unfair to compare them. They really have no links. Ash looks the way she does thanks to doctors. Sarah looks like she does due to mother nature.

Ashlee is more like her sister Jessica but who knows how they really are. We are not to judge.



Wednesday 27 December 2006, by Miffit :

Alright; you can’t compare Ashlee Simpson to Sarah Michelle Gellar. This isn’t a fair comparison.

Ashlee Simpson had plastic surgury and is 22. She’s at her prime of her beauty. f

Sarah Michelle Gellar is going to be turning 30 in april. Hasn’t had any plastic surgery.



Saturday 30 December 2006, by Anonymous :

whoop sarah is b 4r sure

Friday 19 January 2007, by FlyGirl :

...I didn’t know that any two blondes with curly hair look-a-like, cause that’s pretty much what People is saying. Wow...they’re dumb. Both girls are stunning, with or without a little needle here and there, but hard to tell the difference...? Do they think we’re ninnies?

Sunday 28 January 2007, by Anonymous :

Damn, for a second there I couldn’t tell them apart. Simpson could have been her stuny double on the show.

Sunday 18 February 2007, by boost :

Well i think we all know which ones which

Ashlee does look quite pretty in this picture but SARAH MICHELLE GELLAR IS STUNNING! ive always loved her i think she is so perfect and pretty if i could look like anyone id pick her shes been in so many movies has a hot as boyfriend and is pretty and has a great personality yes her nose has always been like that but i think that imperfection just makes her more pretty i envy her so much

peace out



These comments are an anwser to this article : Sarah Michelle Gellar physically compared to Ashlee Simpson by People Magazine

« Previous comment to : "Blade" Tv Series - Tvguide.com Review (buffy mention)
     Next comment to : Michelle Trachtenberg - "The House" Tv Series - She’ll appear on July 5, 2006 in Australia »