Wednesday 29 December 2004, by Anonymous :

Well, besides the fact that the order is all outta whack and they’ve included whole seasons as episodes, thus taking up valuable space (which I think they did because of all those ’nul points’) not a terrible list. Certainly not as bad as the Angel one.

Thursday 30 December 2004, by Anonymous :

actually they did put 25 episodes there, they just gave a rundown of the seasons as well....

Thursday 30 December 2004, by Milly :

I’m not sure I agree with most of the episodes, although they picked my favorite "Passion" in the 25, so I guess the list is somewhat ok. But it doesn’t feel like an order, just feels like "25 of the best episodes of BtVS"

Thursday 30 December 2004, by Anonymous :

This is over a year old! It shipped Nov 20 2003

Thursday 30 December 2004, by Anonymous :

agreed, not as bad as the Angel one, but not great. Band Candy? A New Man? I’m surprised Amends did not get a vote.

Friday 31 December 2004, by Anonymous :

I think who did this list doens´t like Faith! I mean "This years’ girl" and "Who are you?" are incredible episodes and much better than "Lie to me" or "Storyteller"!!! Those eps are my favorites.

Friday 31 December 2004, by Anonymous :

Lover walk on four? Are they insane or something. Can’t take them serious.

Sunday 2 January 2005, by DUSTY :

’CHOSEN’ AND ’END OF DAYS’ SHOULD HAVE BEEN 1 AND 2 NO QUESTION ABOUT IT

Sunday 2 January 2005, by Tara :

This list is all wrong. They probably picked these episodes randomly.And the episodes that were good are behind the not-so-good ones,look at the order. And why do these people hate Sarah that much? "Miss-Self-Absorbed herself" under ’Conversations With Dead People’ and that saying at the end of ’Once More With Feeling’.Lay off.

Saturday 8 January 2005, by Anonymous :

YeAH ....CHOSEN SHOULD HAVE BEEN NUMBER ONE........ I ADORE CHOSEN

Thursday 13 January 2005, by Anonymous :

Just retarded. Plus the ranking makes absolutely no sense. Who the hell writes this stuff? Do they even watch the show??? Band Candy better than The Gift? Storyteller above Becoming? Where are The Prom, The Wish, Seeing Red, Normal Again, Who Are You?, Bad Girls, Enemies or Amends? And what the hell is A New Man doing there? I’m surprised there were no Harmony eps in there just to really make the vein in my temple throb. Also, they contradict their own rankings. They call Becoming the "best season finale of the show" and yet rank 5 of the other 6 finales higher than it.

Saturday 29 January 2005, by Anonymous :

where is Restless? OMG very ver very bad list...The Body had to be number one!

These comments are an anwser to this article : Buffy Episodes Top 25 - Xposé Magazine #24 - Good Quality Scans

« Previous comment to : Christian Kane will star in Steven Spielberg’s New Mini Series
     Next comment to : Remains to be seen, or possibly flung (alyson hannigan mention) »